News | The Investor
24 Aug 2025 22:00
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Business > Features > The Investor

    Are some Companies Too Big to Succeed?

    During the global financial crisis, many banks were bailed out because they were ‘too big to fail’.


    Investment Research Group
    Investment Research Group
    Now research has found that some companies listed on a share market are not good investments because they are ‘too big to succeed’.

    A report by US firm Research Affiliates has found that many large companies in the US can underperform their peers for up to 10 years once they reach the number one position in their sector.

    One thing that happens is that large, dominant companies tend to attract the attention governments and regulators.

    “Was Goldman Sachs targeted with civil and criminal fraud charges because they have criminal intent to defraud their clients, while their competition is pure as the driven snow? Or have they become a symbol of success-to-excess, and pundits to want them to suffer?

    “Is Exxon Mobil regularly pilloried in Washington because people think that their business practices are monopolistic, their profit margins obscene, and their product is polluting and distasteful (never mind that we all buy it)? Or is it because their relentless business success makes them a popular target?

    “Microsoft’s opportunity in the spotlight came a decade ago, when they were attacked on the grounds of ‘monopolistic’ business practices, as was IBM in the prior decade.

    The decade before that, AT&T was successfully dismantled on the same basis.

    Its research has found the leader in any sector underperforms the average stock in its own sector by 3.5% per year for a multi-year period.

    “The damage doesn’t really slow down for at least a decade, as the top dog in each sector lags its own sector by 3.3% per year for the next decade! With compounding, the top stock in the 12 market sectors declined 28% in value relative to the average stock in its respective sector.”

    There is one mitigating factor; in most sectors, the number one position changes frequently. Therefore, it can be worthwhile owning a large, dominant company but it may be better to own number two or three that is on the way up, rather than number one which is sticking its head above the parapet for competitors, regulators and the government to take potshots at.

    A quick look at the New Zealand and Australian markets shows the “too big to succeed” label appears to apply here.

    There are any number of large companies that are regulated by the government or regulatory authorities in the areas of telecommunications, gambling and energy, for example. Many of these companies have underperformed the market in recent years.

    © 2025 David McEwen, NZCity

     Other The Investor News
     12 Sep: Fixed vs. floating rates – which is best for you?
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Otago have moved to fourth on the NPC ladder after a 33-19 victory over the winless Counties Manukau in Dunedin More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    The gas crisis, has left one of our largest companies reassessing its options More...



     Today's News

    Rugby:
    Otago have moved to fourth on the NPC ladder after a 33-19 victory over the winless Counties Manukau in Dunedin 21:57

    Auckland:
    A person is reportedly in a critical condition after becoming trapped in a collapsed sand dune at an Auckland beach 21:17

    Rugby:
    Belief from All Blacks assistant coach Jason Holland that the team can bounce back from their loss to Argentina, with the Springboks set to pounce at Eden Park in less than a fortnight 18:57

    Rugby:
    All Blacks coach Scott Robertson is confident his side can turn things around in less than two weeks as they look towards a blockbuster clash against the Springboks at Eden Park 18:37

    Rugby League:
    The Warriors women have gone down 22-14 to the Sharks in their NRLW clash in Hamilton 18:07

    Motoring:
    NASCAR driver Shane van Gisbergen has finished 16th in the Cup Series regular season finale at Daytona 17:27

    Rugby:
    Excitement is brewing for the Black Ferns ahead of tomorrow morning's World Cup opener against Spain in York 17:17

    Living & Travel:
    An Air New Zealand flight between Auckland and Blenheim had to be diverted to New Plymouth, today because of an electrical issue on board 16:57

    Rugby:
    A call of urgency from All Blacks assistant coach Jason Holland for his backs to improve in the air moving forward 16:17

    Rugby:
    Disappointment from All Blacks fullback Will Jordan with hooker Codie Taylor's 100th game ending on a sour note 15:27


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2025 New Zealand City Ltd