News | Politics
1 Nov 2024 14:10
NZCity News
NZCity CalculatorReturn to NZCity

  • Start Page
  • Personalise
  • Sport
  • Weather
  • Finance
  • Shopping
  • Jobs
  • Horoscopes
  • Lotto Results
  • Photo Gallery
  • Site Gallery
  • TVNow
  • Dating
  • SearchNZ
  • NZSearch
  • Crime.co.nz
  • RugbyLeague
  • Make Home
  • About NZCity
  • Contact NZCity
  • Your Privacy
  • Advertising
  • Login
  • Join for Free

  •   Home > News > Politics

    UNRWA rejects claims of a replacement aid agency, after Israel voted to ban its operations in Gaza and the West Bank

    The UN’s aid agency for Palestinian refugees will be outlawed in 90 days, under a controversial bill backed by Israel’s parliament.


    There is an eerie quiet inside the walls of the United Nation's Palestinian aid agency's compound in East Jerusalem.

    Behind its large metal gate, painted in trademark sky blue, offices and warehouses of the United Nations Relief and Works Agency for Palestine Refugees (UNRWA) once buzzing with activity are half empty.

    "There is a sense of concern because of what may happen in coming months, how we would need to adapt to that," spokesman in Jerusalem Jonathan Fowler tells the ABC.

    "But if we didn't have a sliver of hope, we wouldn't be able to continue doing what we do."

    News of the late night decision by Israel's parliament, the Knesset, to ban UNRWA's operations in Israel and the Occupied Palestinian Territories had kept staff awake into the early hours of the morning.

    In their view, the full impact is still not clear

    "Obviously we have to plan in certain senses for the fact that there would be an attempt to bring down a legal guillotine on our operations within the space of three months," Mr Fowler said.

    "But there are already certain aspects to the legislation passed which indicate that, for example, the authorities need to find alternatives to us.

    "We're clear there is no alternative to UNRWA — but if the authorities are questing for one and do not find it, what does that actually mean in terms of the timeline of the implementation as well?"

    Even before Monday night's vote, only around a quarter of its staff were coming into the compound daily.

    UNRWA said Palestinian employees were being blocked from travelling from the West Bank into East Jerusalem, and Israel was refusing to grant visas to its international staff.

    Some local Israelis had tried to set fire to the compound twice, according to video shared by local media and UNRWA, with fears the alleged arson attacks could ignite fuel kept in the compound.

    In May, the Israel Land Authority informed UNRWA that it had 30 days to vacate its Jerusalem premises, and earlier this month the Israel Land Authority announced it would build some 1,500 housing units on the premises.

    The city's Deputy Mayor Arieh King reportedly threatened to shut off UNRWA's water supply if it did not leave.

    "They're all part of an overall campaign to just get rid of us," Mr Fowler said.

    'If you take the backbone out of the body, the body falls apart'

    The case to ban UNRWA's operations in Israel, the West Bank and Gaza is based on an argument that the agency is a threat to Israel's safety.

    That flows from accusations levelled by Israel that UNRWA staff aided Hamas in the deadly October 7 attacks and in the months after the war in Gaza began.

    "We've always taken those allegations seriously, we have investigated, staff have been fired," Mr Fowler said.

    "I in absolutely no way minimise the nature of the allegations, but the allegations are also entirely unrepresentative of the agency as a whole.

    "Nine people out of an organisation of 30,000 across the region, including 13,000 in the Gaza Strip – in no one's wildest fantasies can that be characterised as the entire organisation being infected, infiltrated."

    Hundreds of UNRWA staff have also been killed during the war in Gaza.

    The legislation now adopted by the Knesset makes it illegal for Israeli officials to deal with the agency.

    The Israel Defense Forces (IDF) control all access in and out of Gaza, including along the territory's border with Egypt – so even if UNRWA wanted to try to get aid in, the IDF would not be allowed to issue permits allowing that to happen.

    It effectively smothers the 75-year-old agency, which is the main provider of food aid, medical services and education for around 3 million Palestinians.

    Israel insists there will be other agencies which can fill the void – a point unsurprisingly disputed by UNRWA.

    "If you take the backbone out of a body, the body falls apart," Mr Fowler said.

    On Tuesday, UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres sent a letter to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu appealing to the government of Israel.

    In the letter, which was seen by reporters of news agency AFP, Mr Guterres said the law could have "devastating consequences" for Palestinians in Gaza and the West Bank because there is no reasonable alternative to UNRWA for providing the aid and assistance these people need.

    He argued that under international law an occupying power must implement mechanisms for aiding the people living in that occupied territory.

    "If Israel is not in a position to meet such needs, it has an obligation to allow and facilitate the activities of the United Nations, including UNRWA, and other humanitarian agencies, until the needs of Palestine refugees in the Occupied Palestinian Territory are met," he said.

    Arab politicians accuse their Jewish counterparts of hypocrisy

    The decision in the Knesset was the culmination of months of fiery rhetoric from the Israeli government and lawmakers outside of Mr Netanyahu's coalition.

    While the final legislation did not go so far as to designate UNRWA as a terrorist organisation – something originally planned but dropped because it was deemed legally problematic – members of the Knesset (MK) repeatedly described the agency of being tied to terrorist activity during the tense debate in the Knesset.

    "We decided that this terror organisation cannot live next to us," bill sponsor MK Ron Katz told the ABC.

    Arab MKs accused their colleagues of double standards – one describing the country of having a "fascist atmosphere".

    "Even in the Knesset there is a minister who is a terrorist and they aren't getting rid of the government," Ahmad Tibi told the chamber.

    He is referring to national security minister Itamar Ben Gvir, who has eight previous convictions, including supporting a terrorist organisation.

    A number of countries, including Australia, suspended funding to UNRWA in January after Israel accused 12 Palestinians of being UNRWA employees who took part in the October 7 attacks.

    Foreign Minister Penny Wong later reinstated Australian contributions, after an independent investigation by the UN.

    Political scientist Menachem Klein from Bar-Ilan University said banning UNRWA will only make the situation worse for Israel, given it will be expected to take up the mantle of providing support to the Palestinian population.

    "Without UNRWA, the problem will be much more severe, much more acute," he said.

    "Israel will be blamed also for the misery of today, not only the past misery."

    He argued the real reason why Israel was trying to dismantle UNRWA was to sideline the issue of Palestinian refugees.

    Australia is among countries criticising Israel for the decision, with the United States suggesting military aid to Israel could be in jeopardy if it cannot guarantee the flow of humanitarian aid into Gaza.

    MK Ron Katz said other countries did not properly understand the situation.

    "They didn't see the evidence, they shouldn't speak," he said.

    "I think that now the world will realise that [UNRWA] wasn't as big as they thought.

    "I think that they're going to see that the Palestinian people … it's going to get even better for them."

    Norway is now flagging it will ask the UN General Assembly to consider a resolution asking the International Court of Justice for an opinion on Israel's obligations to provide aid to Palestinians.

    Palestinian refugees in East Jerusalem too scared to speak out against Israel

    The Shu'fat refugee camp in East Jerusalem lies in the shadow of Israel's West Bank barrier wall.

    It is a community built and supported by UNRWA over decades, after it was established in the 1960s.

    Everyone the ABC spoke to was too scared to publicly criticise Israel, fearful of being targeted by police and security services.

    As residents of East Jerusalem, they can cross into Israel with more ease than other Palestinians in the West Bank and have access to things like Israeli healthcare — rights they do not want to jeopardise.

    But a number of residents – including some who were born in the camp decades ago – said the quality of UNRWA services in the camp had suffered.

    They said Israel made it hard for staff wanting to work in schools and medical clinics to come into the camp daily, passing through militarised checkpoints.

    As the ABC was leaving the camp, dozens of Israeli police decked out in riot gear stormed Shu'fat – a reminder of the iron grip Israel has on the Palestinian population.

    ABC News

    © 2024 ABC Australian Broadcasting Corporation. All rights reserved

     Other Politics News
     01 Nov: Death toll from Spanish flooding disaster jumps to 158 as further weather warnings are issued
     01 Nov: An exclusive private school in Auckland is warning data may have been breached in a cyber attack
     01 Nov: The US presidential election gets the headlines, but Americans will also vote in thousands of down ballot races for everything from judges to tax collectors
     01 Nov: A development in one of New Zealand's oldest property disputes
     01 Nov: Fresh vegetable prices could go through the roof - if changes to freshwater management go ahead
     31 Oct: A call for permanent Police presence on buses and trains, after increasing violence
     31 Oct: Dozens of companies are seeking more robust and clear health and safety regulation
     Top Stories

    RUGBY RUGBY
    Beauden Barrett will have the keys to the All Blacks' attack at Twickenham, after being confirmed to start at 10 against England on Sunday morning More...


    BUSINESS BUSINESS
    Mining must become more responsible and sustainable. Where hi-tech solutions fit in More...



     Today's News

    Rugby:
    Beauden Barrett will have the keys to the All Blacks' attack at Twickenham, after being confirmed to start at 10 against England on Sunday morning 14:07

    Politics:
    Death toll from Spanish flooding disaster jumps to 158 as further weather warnings are issued 14:07

    Entertainment:
    Selena Gomez has likened her 'Wizards of Waverly Place' return to a homecoming 13:49

    International:
    Every vote for Harris and Trump is not created equal 13:47

    Politics:
    An exclusive private school in Auckland is warning data may have been breached in a cyber attack 13:47

    Health & Safety:
    The Ministry of Health has warned the Auditor-General that emergency preparedness is at risk 13:27

    Entertainment:
    Michael Keaton has paid a glowing tribute to his former co-star Teri Garr 13:19

    Business:
    Mining must become more responsible and sustainable. Where hi-tech solutions fit in 13:07

    International:
    Did the Nazis and the CIA help shape the history of LSD? 13:07

    Christchurch:
    Fire crews are battling a house fire in central Christchurch 13:07


     News Search






    Power Search


    © 2024 New Zealand City Ltd